Studying in a place is not only a ‘necessary evil’

Of course, if you go and speak to people in person then this has to occur in a ‘place’. I did not only go to ‘places’, I selected these places and the people and groups to interact with because of their relationship to a suburb (which is an administratively defined place).

Life in ‘advanced capitalist societies’ such as Australia is often described as ‘unbounded’ (e.g. Bauman). However, regardless of whether such a description is accurate, place is still a salient methodological grounding for exploring some aspects of the social world.

I agree with those who suggest that a study based around a place is not the same as one centred on a set of social relationships (e.g. Amit & Rapport 2002), but the case has also been made that, even for understanding the creation and practice of networked communities, neighbourhood scale geographies can still be significant (Clark 2009: 1573).

In the conclusion of Carrithers’ entry on field work in the Encyclopedia of Social and Cultural Anthropology, Kumar’s remarks on the end of her fieldwork are quoted:

‘I was interacting with only a few informants on one level but on many other levels I was interacting with other components of the city. I felt beyond the shadow of a doubt that I was interacting with the city itself.’ (Carrithers 2002: 231).

I never felt I was able to interact with the suburb of Port Melbourne itself. However, I have no regrets (yet) about choosing to base my project not just on, but also in, a suburb.



Amit, V. and N. Rapport (2002). The trouble with community : anthropological reflections on movement, identity and collectivity. London & Sterling, Pluto.


Carrithers, M. (2002). Fieldwork. Encyclopedia of social and cultural anthropology. A. Barnard and J. Spencer. London & New York, Routledge: 229-231.


Clark, A. (2009). “From neighbourhood to network: a review of the significance of neighbourhood in studies of social relations.” Geography Compass 3(4): 1559-1578.

This entry was posted in About my project and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Studying in a place is not only a ‘necessary evil’

  1. Alex Leiva says:

    Hi, I recently bought an apartment in Port Melbourne and I was curious about the demographics in there so I found your blog and I find it very interesting.
    My wife and I are so excited to move there!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s